The Baltimore Orioles are on the hunt for pitching power, and the latest name on their radar is Lucas Giolito, a potential game-changer. But here's where it gets intriguing: while the team has been linked to several big names, Giolito's inclusion raises some eyebrows. Is he the missing piece they've been searching for?
The Orioles have been busy bolstering their starting rotation, recently acquiring Shane Baz and re-signing Zach Eflin, while trading away Grayson Rodriguez for Taylor Ward. With Trevor Rogers, Kyle Bradish, Baz, and Eflin already in the mix, the team seems to have a solid foundation. But is it enough?
The modern game demands a deep pitching roster, and the Orioles have options with Tyler Wells, Chayce McDermott, Cade Povich, and Brandon Young, although they haven't quite found their stride in the majors. Albert Suárez adds veteran experience on a minor league deal, and Trey Gibson, a top pitching prospect, is knocking on the door for a debut.
However, the team's current rotation lacks a true ace. While Rogers had a stellar 2025 season, he faced injury setbacks and a delayed return from the minors. Bradish and Baz show potential, but their recent performances haven't been consistently dominant. And this is the part most people miss: the Orioles' 2025 rotation, filled with older veterans, didn't live up to expectations.
Enter Giolito, who once appeared to be an ace in the making. From 2019 to 2021, he delivered impressive numbers with the White Sox, earning Cy Young votes each year. But his performance dipped in the following seasons, and a UCL surgery in 2024 further complicated matters. He rebounded in 2025 with the Red Sox, but his strikeout rates were notably lower.
The Orioles' interest in Giolito is understandable, especially considering their current rotation. The 2019-2021 version of Giolito would be a significant upgrade, even if his recent numbers don't match those of Framber Valdez, who is expected to command a higher price. With a projected payroll of $148MM for the upcoming year, the Orioles have some financial flexibility to make a move.
But is Giolito the right choice? While he could provide a boost, his recent performance might not be the game-changer the Orioles need. And this is where opinions may differ: is Giolito worth the investment, or should the Orioles explore other options? The team's decision will undoubtedly shape their season, and fans are eager to see how this pitching puzzle comes together.
